Checking a Wagner cast iron skillet for age, defects, and collectability. Before you purchase your first Wagner skillet, it’s a good idea to check the condition to ensure you’ll be happy with the purchase. Carefully inspecting the skillet also helps you avoid disappointment and makes using vintage ironware much more enjoyable.
Inspecting vintage cast iron pans and looking for faults could prevent you from overpaying or help you negotiate a better price with the seller. And when you spot a bargain, you’ll be easily able to judge the condition of the pan so you can make a decision right then and there.
Table of Contents
- Inspecting a Wagner skillet
- Pans without the Sidney O marking
- Availability of Wagner skillets
- Conclusion: How to check a Wagner cast iron skillet
How To Check A Vintage Wagner Cast Iron Skillet
Choose Your Favorite Logo
Wagner changed the logo on their pans several times over the years. Skillets with the stylized logo are popular and well-known. But there are older Wagner skillets with slight logo variations for you to find. Older skillets are less common, making finding them much more fun.
Is One Logo Better Than Another?
I wouldn’t fuss over looking for one logo over another. Sure, you want to watch for the elusive pie logo pans. But I think a lot of people regard the Wagner logos the same.
I also do not strongly prefer the early logos over the stylized Wagner logo, and I think you’ll be happy with any Wagner pan.
So, I’d place more importance on the condition of the skillet and not on the type of logo on the back.
How To Inspect A Wagner Cast Iron Skillet
When you see a Wagner skillet, there are a couple of buying considerations. And I’m sure you can look beyond some of these faults if you see a bargain at a thrift store. But you might want to be choosy if the seller’s asking price is high. After all, plenty of vintage ironware is around, and there’s no need to FOMO in at the first skillet you see.
Should I Buy A Rusty Wagner Pan?
When looking for vintage ironware, I’m unsure if rust is a negative or a positive. Sure, you’d like to find a Wagner skillet in excellent condition. But often, the best bargains can be found when the skillets are a little worse for wear.
I understand you’d prefer one in good shape for your first pan. But removing rust is not hard. And with some time and effort, you can bring the pan back to its former glory. So, I wouldn’t disregard a pan with some surface rust.
Rust Can Hide A Much Larger Problem
I recommend not to hesitate if you see a rusty Wagner skillet at a great price. However, rust can hide hairline cracks. Unfortunately, spotting these cracks until you remove the rust is difficult. Even cast iron restorers that buy and sell cast iron regularly find it difficult to identify potential fractures in the cookware until they start cleaning the iron.
Check The Skillet For Cracks
You can check for cracks if the pan does not have much rust. Check the sides of the pan for fractures in the iron, particularly around the handle where the pan is under more stress.
Unfortunately, hairline cracks may not be noticeable from a glance. So, take your time to inspect the pan. Understandably, the skillet will have little collectability if it has a crack. Cooking with oil may pose a fire risk.
Does Sulfur Pitting Affect Collectability?
Sulfur pitting on the base of the skillet will not affect its usability. It adds character and highlights your cooking with vintage cast iron.
However, sulfur pitting will reduce the desirability of the cookware. So, if you’re considering collecting Wagner Ware, this could be a consideration. Otherwise, I wouldn’t worry about the base. I hesitate to buy the skillet only when the cooking surface has pitting.
Does A Wobble Or Movement In A Wagner Skillet Matter?
When inspecting a Wagner skillet, checking for movement is a good idea. Lay the pan down on a flat surface. With your fingers, press down along the rim of the pan.
If the pan rocks, the base is not entirely flat. It may be unsuitable for flat cooking elements such as glass and ceramic induction.
But if the pan has a tiny amount of movement, I wouldn’t worry about it. However, it is a good idea to check the pan for warp, as Wagner Ware pans can wobble.
Don’t get me wrong, Wagner made excellent cast iron cookware. And it’s a favorite among collectors. And if you’re wondering if Wagner cast iron is any good, you may find this article interesting.
Another consideration when buying an antique Wagner skillet is the condition of the cooking surface. Over the years, the cooking surface has likely suffered a few scrapes and scratches. Kitchen utensils and kitchen knives can make visible marks on the cooking surface.
Most of these scratches will fill in over time as the seasoning layer on the skillet builds. However, deeper scratches from kitchen knives may leave nasty visible marks, and the only way to get these out is through gentle restoration.
Pans Without The Sidney O Marking
There are older Wagner cast iron skillets only with the Wagner wording. However, most have the recognizable Wagner Ware Sidney 0 marking. These are the pans that are considered collectible.
However, there are many later pans without the Sidney 0 marking. These skillets are post-1960 and made under different ownership. And I would avoid overpaying for these pans. Consider them skillets for daily use rather than highly collectible ironware.
To learn the Wagner Manufacturing history and logos, check out this articl
Availability Of Wagner Cast Iron Skillets
Another consideration when buying a Wagner skillet is the amount of vintage Wagner cast iron available. Trust me, there isn’t a shortage, and there’s no hurry to purchase.
I recommend taking your time and choosing a skillet that suits your needs. You might want to wait until you find a pan with your favorite Wagner logo or your preferred size.
Conclusion: How To Check A Wagner Cast Iron Skillet
These are a few considerations when buying a vintage Wagner skillet. It’s easy to rush and buy the first frying pan you see. But there isn’t any rush, and you can take your time to research the different skillets available.
Look around this site to learn more about vintage cast iron. Other websites, such as the Cast Iron Collector or Facebook groups, can provide helpful buying advice.
But most importantly, have fun looking and buying your first Wagner skillet. They are exceedingly good pans to use.